Making an Informed Decision: A Guide to Three Common Approaches to Phalloplasty Surgery

Headshot of serious young trans man with hand on chin

Phalloplasty surgery is a surgical procedure that involves the construction or reconstruction of a penis for transgender individuals. This surgery is a significant step for many trans people seeking to align their body with their gender identity. Phalloplasty can also be a complex and invasive procedure that requires careful consideration before making a decision.

As such, it is important to discuss the different types of phalloplasty surgeries available to transgender individuals. Each type of phalloplasty has its own set of advantages, disadvantages, and potential complications. Understanding the different options available can help transgender individuals make informed decisions about their surgical options and choose the best option for their individual needs and goals. In this blog post, we will explore the various types of phalloplasty surgeries available and provide some key considerations to keep in mind when making a decision.

Types of phalloplasty surgeries

There are several types of phalloplasty surgeries available, each with its own unique set of advantages, disadvantages, and potential complications. In this section, we will explore three of the most common types of phalloplasty surgeries: radial forearm phalloplasty, anterolateral thigh phalloplasty, and alt-phalloplasty.

  1. Radial forearm phalloplasty is a popular type of phalloplasty that involves taking skin and tissue from the forearm to construct a penis. The procedure involves creating a flap of skin and tissue from the forearm, which is then rolled and shaped into a phallus. The urethra is typically created using a graft of oral mucosa or a piece of intestine, and erectile function can be achieved through the use of a penile prosthesis or by transferring a nerve from the clitoris to the phallus.Description of the procedure: Anterolateral thigh phalloplasty involves using skin and tissue from the thigh to construct a phallus. The procedure begins with the creation of a flap of skin and tissue from the thigh, which is then rolled and shaped into a phallus. The urethra is created using a graft of oral mucosa or a piece of the intestine. Erectile function can be achieved through the use of a penile prosthesis or by transferring a nerve from the clitoris to the phallus. The phallus is typically attached to the pubic bone and the blood vessels are reconnected to ensure proper blood flow. The procedure can take several hours to complete and requires a highly skilled surgeon. Recovery from anterolateral thigh phalloplasty typically takes several weeks to a few months and may involve wearing a compression garment, avoiding heavy lifting, and engaging in physical therapy.

    Advantages: The radial forearm phalloplasty has a high success rate and produces a phallus that closely resembles a natural penis. The procedure also allows for the creation of a urethra, which can improve urinary function.

    Disadvantages: The procedure can result in visible scarring on the forearm, and there is a risk of nerve damage or loss of sensation in the donor site. Erectile function may also be limited without the use of a prosthesis.Risks and complications: Potential risks and complications of radial forearm phalloplasty include infection, bleeding, hematoma, nerve damage, tissue necrosis, and urinary complications.

    Recovery time and aftercare: Recovery from radial forearm phalloplasty typically takes several weeks to a few months. Aftercare may include wearing a compression garment, avoiding heavy lifting, and engaging in physical therapy.

  1. Anterolateral thigh phalloplasty is another type of phalloplasty that involves taking skin and tissue from the thigh to construct a penis. The procedure involves creating a flap of skin and tissue from the thigh, which is then rolled and shaped into a phallus. The urethra is typically created using a graft of oral mucosa or a piece of intestine, and erectile function can be achieved through the use of a penile prosthesis or by transferring a nerve from the clitoris to the phallus.Description of the procedure: Radial forearm phalloplasty involves using skin and tissue from the forearm to construct a phallus. The procedure typically begins with the creation of a flap of skin and tissue from the forearm, which is then rolled and shaped into a phallus. The urethra is created using a graft of oral mucosa or a piece of the intestine. Erectile function can be achieved through the use of a penile prosthesis or by transferring a nerve from the clitoris to the phallus. The phallus is typically attached to the pubic bone and the blood vessels are reconnected to ensure proper blood flow. The procedure can take several hours to complete and requires a highly skilled surgeon. Recovery from radial forearm phalloplasty typically takes several weeks to a few months and may involve wearing a compression garment, avoiding heavy lifting, and engaging in physical therapy.

    Advantages: Anterolateral thigh phalloplasty can result in less visible scarring than radial forearm phalloplasty, and there is a lower risk of nerve damage or loss of sensation in the donor site.

    Disadvantages: The procedure can result in asymmetry in the thigh, and the resulting phallus may be less rigid than with other types of phalloplasty.Risks and complications: Potential risks and complications of anterolateral thigh phalloplasty include infection, bleeding, hematoma, nerve damage, tissue necrosis, and urinary complications.

    Recovery time and aftercare: Recovery from anterolateral thigh phalloplasty typically takes several weeks to a few months. Aftercare may include wearing a compression garment, avoiding heavy lifting, and engaging in physical therapy.

  1. Alt-phalloplasty is a newer type of phalloplasty that involves the use of a composite graft from multiple donor sites to construct a penis. The procedure involves taking skin and tissue from the forearm, thigh, and other areas to create a phallus. The urethra is typically created using a graft of oral mucosa or a piece of intestine, and erectile function can be achieved through the use of a penile prosthesis or by nerve transfers from the clitoris to the phallus.Description of the procedure: Alt-phalloplasty is a complex surgical procedure that involves using multiple donor sites to create a phallus. The procedure begins by taking skin and tissue from the forearm, thigh, and other areas of the body to create a composite graft. The graft is then shaped and rolled into a phallus, and the urethra is created using a graft of oral mucosa or a piece of intestine. Erectile function can be achieved through the use of a penile prosthesis or by transferring a nerve from the clitoris to the phallus.

    Advantages: Alt-phalloplasty allows for the creation of a larger phallus than other types of phalloplasty, and it can result in less visible scarring. The procedure also has a lower risk of nerve damage or loss of sensation in the donor sites.

    Disadvantages: Alt-phalloplasty is a complex procedure that requires a highly skilled surgeon and a longer recovery time than other types of phalloplasty. The procedure also has a higher risk of complications, including tissue necrosis and urinary complications.Risks and complications: Potential risks and complications of alt-phalloplasty include infection, bleeding, hematoma, nerve damage, tissue necrosis, and urinary complications.

    Recovery time and aftercare: Recovery from alt-phalloplasty can take several months to a year. Aftercare may include wearing a compression garment, avoiding heavy lifting, and engaging in physical therapy.

Comparison of the different types of phalloplasty surgeries: When choosing a type of phalloplasty surgery, there are several factors to consider, including the size and appearance of the phallus, the amount of scarring, the risk of complications, and the recovery time. Radial forearm phalloplasty produces a phallus that closely resembles a natural penis, but there is a risk of visible scarring on the forearm. Anterolateral thigh phalloplasty can result in less visible scarring, but the resulting phallus may be less rigid than with other types of phalloplasty. Alt-phalloplasty allows for the creation of a larger phallus with less visible scarring, but it is a more complex procedure with a higher risk of complications and a longer recovery time.

Factors to consider when choosing a type of phalloplasty surgery: In addition to the factors mentioned above, it is important to consider individual preferences and goals when choosing a type of phalloplasty surgery. Some individuals may prioritize the appearance of the phallus, while others may prioritize function or recovery time. It is important to discuss these factors with a qualified surgeon and mental health professional to make an informed decision.

Pros and cons of each type of phalloplasty surgery: Overall, each type of phalloplasty surgery has its own set of pros and cons. Radial forearm phalloplasty produces a phallus that closely resembles a natural penis, but there is a risk of visible scarring on the forearm. Anterolateral thigh phalloplasty can result in less visible scarring, but the resulting phallus may be less rigid than with other types of phalloplasty. Alt-phalloplasty allows for the creation of a larger phallus with less visible scarring, but it is a more complex procedure with a higher risk of complications and a longer recovery time. Ultimately, the best type of phalloplasty surgery will depend on individual goals, preferences, and medical considerations.

Other considerations for phalloplasty surgery

There are several other important concerns to keep in mind when evaluating phalloplasty surgery. These considerations include:

Timing of surgery: Phalloplasty surgery is typically not performed until after a person has undergone hormone therapy and has lived as their desired gender for a period of time. The exact timing of surgery will depend on individual factors and should be discussed with a qualified surgeon.

Pre-operative requirements: Before undergoing phalloplasty surgery, individuals may need to undergo certain medical tests and evaluations. These requirements may include blood tests, imaging tests, and consultations with mental health professionals.

Post-operative care and follow-up: After undergoing phalloplasty surgery, individuals will need to engage in post-operative care and follow-up. This may include taking medications, attending physical therapy, and attending follow-up appointments with the surgeon to monitor healing and address any complications.

Conclusion

Phalloplasty surgery can be an important step for transgender individuals seeking to align their body with their gender identity. However, it is important to carefully consider all options and work with qualified healthcare professionals to make an informed decision. In this blog post, we have explored the different types of phalloplasty surgeries available, including radial forearm phalloplasty, anterolateral thigh phalloplasty, and alt-phalloplasty. Each type of phalloplasty has its own set of advantages, disadvantages, risks, and complications, and individuals should consider their own individual goals and preferences when making a decision.

It is crucial to consult with a qualified medical doctor and surgeon before making a decision about phalloplasty surgery. These professionals can help individuals understand the risks and benefits of each procedure and make an informed decision. We encourage individuals to consider all options and make the best decision for themselves based on their needs and goals.

Disclaimer: This blog shares general information only, not professional advice or recommendations. Consult healthcare providers for personal guidance. Decisions based on content are the reader's responsibility. Thank you.

Clayre runs a group practice of three queer and trans therapists, including youth therapist Audrey Wolfe, RCC, LGBT therapist Camber Giberson, RCC, CCC, and gender-affirming therapist Clayre Sessoms, RP, RCT, RCC, CCC, ATR-P. Work with us: book a session.

Related Posts